Birding

twittering....

    follow me on Twitter

    dopplr

    From the Gaping Void

    Food for thought

    « A planner's best friend | Main | Unconstructive criticism »

    November 12, 2006

    Comments

    Richard

    The thing that gets me is that Adam Lury wrote it in 1994...and did something about it by bringing into the agency sales promotion and direct people from IMP (some of which have gone on to found the very successful if rather unimpressive VCCP)and PR people. there weren't any digital people because no one had heard of the internet.

    Makes me think that the advertising world has regressed not progressed over the last decade.

    Sad then that in the UK the radical agencies have died or are left shadows of their former selves and the dullards have triumphed - both the old skool and the re-tread 'collaboration' fetishists.

    No Crispin Porter, No Anomaly and no Modernista. We survive on Weidens alone. and I don't think they are even on the same page that HHCL were a decade ago.

    Rob @ Cynic

    As another ex-HHCL'er [is that a word?] I totally agree with you Richard.

    It's not that Cripin's [another ex-employer of mine] and the like are bad - they're not - I just feel they often shine because the rest of the industry have declined into a pit of mediocrity.

    OK, so that's a bit harsh - but at HHCL it was about bravery with intelligence, not just humour with a logo - and when I look at what is happening out there in adland, I am somewhat disappointed to see we are entering the age of devolution.

    Daniel Longchamps

    Bravery and intelligence: I like that. They seem to be 2 words that really form the basis of innovative, interesting communication.
    While I don't work in advertising, I can see from Richard and Rob's comments that the agency and it's people were pretty special. Maybe everyone who worked there should come together and form the advertising version of a supergroup; the industry and the people could do with it.

    Gareth

    Bravery with intelligence - that's fantastic. It's what every agency should be about, yet very few are.

    I totally agree with Richard's point. It makes me sad to think how the industry really has not evolved in the last decade in either its thinking or actions. And he makes a good point about what made HHCL (and maybe St Luke's) special - they didn't just talk about stuff philosophically, they did things to change agency life whether it was hotdesking, tissue meetings or bringing other communication disciplines into the agency.

    jon leach

    Really glad you have found this - I have a copy and was thinking of scanning it in and putting it up somewhere. Thanks for doing it.

    If you get any heat from doing this let me know and I'll contact Adam to keep it in the public domain.

    And it is great stuff.

    mikej

    I think this is great. I have had a fascination with the whole idea of change for years and all the areas I have thought about are covered here

    I love the idea of Bravery and Intelligence for the position of an agency. Because thats what a client should pay an outside company for. If they wanted the same thing or the simple things agencies have been feeding them for years.

    They could just do it themselves

    Rob @ Cynic

    I remember talking to a lovely lady at HHCL, Lousie Vanstone, about this whole intelligence / bravery thing and she said [if memory serves me] that bravey without intelligence is just stupidity with an inflated ego.

    The work was great because the thinking was great - it wasn't Planning Vs Creative, it was HHCL Vs The [Ad] World.

    Noah Brier

    Just wanted to thank you for sharing this. It's quite inspiring.

    Charles Frith

    A bit gobsmacked after reading this last night to find it so prescient and loaded with contemporary language as well as communication ideas. I also found few thoughts that I thought were my own recently!. False memory syndrome at it's best. Adam Lury... what a champ. Well done and thank you.

    Stuart Parkinson

    Jesus. The book I now don't need to write, or maybe I do? We've got to keep plugging away I guess...

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment

    Your Information

    (Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)


    Age of Conversation

    Traffic by


    Blog powered by Typepad

    All the views


    • expressed on this blog are those of their author alone.

    Battle of The Ad Blogs 2006